Practical guide to banking disputes in Italy: Anatocism, usury, abusive mortgage clauses, online scams, and your rights under PSD2. Expert legal analysis by Avvocato Carlo Carta.
Avv. Carlo Carta
Banking and Financial Law Expert
Anatocism is the generation of interest on interest that has already accrued and remains unpaid. When you fail to pay the interest owed to the bank, it gets "capitalized" and becomes the basis for calculating new interest. This practice can significantly inflate your debt over time.
WARNING: Actions for anatocism have a 10-year statute of limitations for operations prior to 2010.
According to Art. 644 of the Criminal Code and Art. 1815 of the Civil Code, a loan contract is usurious if it provides for interest rates that exceed, at the date of signing, the average rate published by the Bank of Italy, increased by half.
EFFECTIVE RATE > AVERAGE RATE + (AVERAGE RATE × 50%) = USURY
Average rates are published at www.bancaditalia.it
The nominal rate exceeds the threshold rate
The threshold is exceeded after signing
The APR (all-inclusive) exceeds the threshold rate
If the contract is usurious, the interest clause is VOID and interest is reduced to legal rates (significantly lower and calculated at the pro tempore legal rate).
2024 LAW UPDATE: In cases of supervening usury, the borrower has the right to reimbursement of interest exceeding the threshold rate and to recalculation of the amortization schedule.
Contract provisions that, in violation of the principle of good faith, determine a significant imbalance between the rights and obligations of the parties to the detriment of the consumer.
Limits the rate to a minimum even if market rates fall
Excessive fees for loan prepayment
Loan processing fees not detailed or hidden
Allows bank to modify conditions at will
Precisely identify the illegitimate clause
Verify if the bank has already applied the effects
Calculate the amount to request for reimbursement
Out-of-court claim → then judicial if necessary
Fake emails impersonating your bank
Scammer obtains a new SIM with your number
Software stealing credentials and OTP codes
Calls where someone pretends to be your bank
In case of unauthorized payment, the bank must immediately refund the amount, unless it proves that the customer acted with intent or gross negligence.
The bank must immediately refund in case of phishing, EVEN IF the customer acted with negligence. The burden of proof lies with the bank.
Immediately contact your bank to block transactions
Report to the Postal Police
Keep all documentation (bank statements, screenshots)
Send written complaint to the bank
If not refunded, proceed judicially
Collect bank statements from the last 10 years, contract, communications
Trust a specialized lawyer or technical consultant
Send by Registered Mail with Acknowledgment of Receipt or PEC, specifying irregularities and requests
30 days to respond. If they refuse or don't respond, you can proceed
Appeal to the Banking Financial Arbiter (free) or go to court
Situation
Customer with systematic overdrafts for 5 years. Bank applied quarterly capitalization.
Action
Analytical account reconstruction and calculation of undue interest.
Result
Reimbursement €28,500 + legal interest
Situation
Customer robbed of €62,300. Bank refused to refund.
Action
Legal action based on PSD2 and Italian Supreme Court ruling.
Result
Bank ordered to fully refund + interest
Situation
Mortgage with floor at 3.5% while Euribor rates were at -0.5%.
Action
Action for nullity of clause and rate redetermination.
Result
Monthly payment from €950 to €720 + refund of differences
Situation
APR exceeded threshold rate by 8 percentage points.
Action
Technical expert report and recovery action.
Result
Reimbursement €45,000 + cancellation of future interest
Every case is different. Contact me for a personalized analysis of your situation.
Want to Verify Your Position?
Upload your bank statement for a free pre-analysis on compound capitalization.
Don't face your bank alone. Get a free preliminary consultation to assess your situation and understand your options.
30+ years of legal experience. Professional consultation in Italian and English.
© 2026 Avvocato Carlo Carta. All rights reserved.